HISTORIC DOCUMENTS
Article 34 of the French Constitution
- Article 34 of the French Constitution guarantees the women the right to terminate pregnancies. This was introduced to their Constitution in 2024 after seeing Roe v. Wade overturned in the U.S. Abortion had been decriminalized since 1975. There were lots of protests for and against the law being added. It bothered many people and was seen by some as unnecessary. It was a direct criticism of the U.S. government, which feels feminist killjoy to me. It also secured the rights for all women, and guaranteed bodily autonomy. Macron suggested adding this amendment. In France, it seems that the morality of abortion is less debated, and there is nothing partisan about it. Additionally in France, abortion is covered by universal healthcare. There are lots of feminist killjoys in France who fought for abortion rights, including Simone de Beauvoir, who wrote and signed Manifesto 343 in 1971. There were 343 signatures that demanded access to contraception and abortions. Overall we can see large strides being made in France, and the addition of guaranteed abortion rights in the French Constitution is monumental.
***
“Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District, 393 U.S. 503 (1969).” JUSTIALaw. https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/393/503/.
- This famous Supreme Court case, so famous it is one of the cases taught to thousands of high school AP Government and US Politics students every year, was a fight between high school students and their school district. John and Mary Beth Tinker, along with Christopher Eckhardt and several other students, decided to begin wearing black armbands to school as a protest to the ongoing conflict in Vietnam. Upon their arrival at school, they were suspended for refusing to remove their armbands and told only to come back when they were ready to remove them. The parents of John and Mary Beth sued the school district, but lost in the Southern Iowa District Court and then in the appeals court, when the case was then taken to the Supreme Court. Not only did the Tinkers refuse to abide by the rules of the school district that limited their right to free speech, which consequently disallowed them from speaking out against the conflict in Vietnam, but after they lost their case twice, they refused to stay down and took their case to the supreme court where they eventually won. This case embodies the feminist killjoy spirit because they refused to let an injustice stand, and pushed back against those who were trying to silence them until their message was heard by more people then they could have ever imagined.
***
Eleanor Roosevelt, “Letter from Eleanor Roosevelt to President General of the DAR.”
- The Daughters of the American Revolution (DAR) is a patriotic organization composed of women who can trace their lineage back to a Revolutionary War contributor, such as an officer, soldier, or supporter. In 1939, they barred world-renowned black singer Marian Anderson from singing at their Constitution Hall in Washington, D.C. Following this instance of discrimination perpetrated by such a large group, which Eleanor Roosevelt was involved with at the time, national attention was brought to the issue of continued discrimination in the US. Eleanor Roosevelt swiftly notified the president of DAR that she would be resigning from the organization because of their discrimination against Anderson. By making her resignation public, Eleanor Roosevelt made it clear that she would not stand for discrimination, showing the rest of the country that she believed it was wrong, which would have been a powerful statement for the time. By resigning from a powerful group of elite white women in defense of a black woman, Roosevelt pushed back against the norms of the time. By disregarding the embarrassment and discomfort she would have caused the entirety of DAR, Roosevelt truly embodied the feminist killjoy spirit.
***
Blackmun, Harry A, and Supreme Court Of The United States. U.S. Reports: Roe v. Wade, 410U.S. 113. 1972. Periodical. https://www.loc.gov/item/usrep410113/.
- I nominate the 1973 U.S. Supreme Court case Roe v. Wade to the feminist killjoy toolkit. This historic case established the right to an abortion in the United States and disrupted patriarchal norms aimed at controlling women’s bodily autonomy. At the center of the case was a woman named Norma McCorvey, who, under the pseudonym “Jane Roe”, challenged the Texas law that made abortion illegal except when the mother’s life was at risk. McCorvey became a symbol of the movement to protect reproductive rights nationwide. Her legal team argued that the Texas law was in violation of her privacy, as enshrined in the Due Process Clause of the 14thAmendment. In a 7-2 decision, the Supreme Court sided with Roe, setting precedent in the U.S. until it was tragically overturned in 2022. The importance of this case cannot be overstated. The legal right to abortion has saved countless lives across the United States, all thanks to McCorvey’s outstanding bravery. Her legal battle and the legacy of this case exemplify what it means to be a feminist killjoy. McCorvey disrupted inequitable systems of power in the face of oppression, inspiring and protecting women all across America, even to this day.
***
The Combahee River Collective Statement
- For my first tool kit, I nominate “Combahee River Collective Statement” because it is a powerful document for understanding how systems of oppression work together, not
independently. This statement was written by a group of Black feminists, and they questioned both mainstream feminisms, which tended to prioritize white women, and
antiracist movements, which tended to ignore Black women’s experiences. One of its major contributions is its focus on the relationships of racial, sexual, heterosexual and
class discrimination. The Collective claims that these forms of inequality are not discrete issues, but rather are interlocking systems that shape the everyday lives of people. For
example, a Black woman may experience racism and sexism, but those don’t necessarily happen separately. Her experience is then shaped by both her race and gender together. This view from the reading forces the reader to think about the ways identity, power, and social structures work together. The statement also shows how political organizing can come from someone’s own experience and collective struggle, making it a both theoretical and practical text. What I mean by that is it is written for the explanation of how oppression and power work, and then to take that knowledge and create action for social change. In conclusion, the Combahee River Collective Statement deserves to be in my feminist tool kit because the statement challenges
traditional approaches to liberation and offers a broader view of oppression and resistance.
***
Stanton, Elizabeth Cady. “Declaration of Sentiments.” In Report of the Woman’s Rights Convention, Held at Seneca Falls, New York, July 19th and 20th, 1848: Proceedings and Declaration of Sentiments. Rochester, NY: John Dick at the North Star Office, 1848. Library of Congress. https://www.loc.gov/item/rbcmiller001106/
- For my next contribution to the Feminist Killjoy Toolkit, I would like to nominate the Declaration of Sentiments from the Seneca Falls Convention in 1848. What stood out to me most was how the women who wrote it took ideas Americans already talked about, like freedom and equality, and basically asked why those ideas did not seem to include women. The document was modeled after the Declaration of Independence, but changed the famous line to say that “all men and women are created equal.” I really like that because they were not creating some completely new idea. They were using America’s own words and showing the contradiction between what the country claimed to believe and how women were actually being treated. The document also called out things like women not being able to vote and having very little say in laws that affected their own lives. I think that took a lot of courage because some of these ideas, especially women voting, were seen as radical at the time. To me, this is what makes the Declaration of Sentiments feel so feminist killjoy. Instead of staying quiet or accepting that this was just the way things were, these women made people uncomfortable by pointing out something that was unfair. I think it belongs in the toolkit because it shows that sometimes change starts with being willing to say that something everyone else has accepted as normal is actually not normal or fair at all.
***
Truth, Sojourner. “Women’s Rights Convention.” Speech delivered at the Ohio Women’s Rights
Convention, Akron, OH, May 29, 1851. Transcribed by Marius Robinson. Anti-Slavery Bugle
(New-Lisbon, OH), June 21, 1851, 160. Chronicling America, Library of Congress.
https://www.loc.gov/item/sn83035487/1851-06-21/ed-1/
- For this entry, I chose Sojourner Truth’s speech at the 1851 Women’s Rights Convention in
Akron, Ohio, because it directly challenged the way people thought about women, strength, and
equality. What stood out to me most was how Truth pushed back against the idea that women
were naturally weaker than men. She talked about the hard physical work she had done and
basically asked how anyone could say women were less capable when her own life proved
otherwise. I also think the speech is especially powerful because Truth was speaking as a Black
woman who had been enslaved, so her experience with womanhood was very different from the
kind of womanhood society often talked about. She was not someone who had been protected or
treated as delicate, yet she was still denied equal rights. To me, that contradiction is what makes
this speech fit so well into the Feminist Killjoy Toolkit. Truth was willing to stand in front of a
crowd and point out that the arguments being used to limit women did not even make sense
when compared to her own life. Something else I found interesting is that the version published
only a few weeks after the speech does not actually include the famous phrase “Ain’t I a
Woman?” That made me think more about how history gets remembered and retold. I think this
speech belongs in the toolkit because Truth forces people to question who gets included when we
talk about women’s rights and equality.